Quick answer
In parcelLab and ShipStation’s 57-retailer U.S. test, 25 retailers, or 43.86%, showed no arrival estimate in the mini-cart. In the separate product-page-and-checkout comparison, 33.3% showed a generic day-count range and 33.3% used a specific date. Put a credible estimate where the shopper is deciding, and say when it becomes a firm promise.
parcelLab and ShipStation, U.S. eCommerce Shipping Experience Study 2025
Key findings and sources
43.86% of tested mini-carts lacked an arrival estimate
Convo Rescue’s calculation from parcelLab and ShipStation’s 2025 U.S. test finds that 25 of 57 large retailers, or 43.86%, lacked a delivery estimate in the mini-cart. The source reports one test purchase per retailer.
parcelLab and ShipStation, U.S. eCommerce Shipping Experience Study 2025
Large U.S. retailer sample, February to March 2025. Subtract the 32 reporting an estimate from 57 and divide by 57.
Two different date formats accounted for 66.6% of observations
In the parcelLab and ShipStation product-page-and-checkout comparison, generic day-count ranges and specific calendar dates each represented 33.3%. The combined 66.6% covers two different levels of precision.
parcelLab and ShipStation, U.S. eCommerce Shipping Experience Study 2025
Same figure’s format categories for the large U.S. retailer sample. Add the two displayed one-decimal shares.
63.1% used one of three explicitly dated formats
In Figure 07 of the 2025 parcelLab and ShipStation U.S. study, the shares for a specific date, calendar date range and receive-by date summed to 63.1% using the chart’s published rounded values.
parcelLab and ShipStation, U.S. eCommerce Shipping Experience Study 2025
Figure 07 formats, not an arrival accuracy measure. Sum 33.3%, 21.1% and 8.7%.
Calendar date ranges exceeded receive-by dates by 12.4 points
The 2025 parcelLab and ShipStation study’s product-page-and-checkout comparison shows 21.1% in the calendar date range category and 8.7% in the receive-by category, a 12.4 percentage-point gap.
parcelLab and ShipStation, U.S. eCommerce Shipping Experience Study 2025
The published Figure 07 comparison. Subtract the receive-by share from the calendar date range share.
Compare the results
25 of 57 mini-carts gave no delivery estimate
Some mini-carts gave shoppers no arrival estimate before they could move to checkout.
Put the first useful estimate before the shopper has to ask
A shopper buying for Friday needs to know whether the order can arrive Friday. “Two business days” leaves them to guess when the seller will pack it, what cutoff applies and whether the carrier works over the weekend. In the 57-retailer test, only 32 mini-carts contained any delivery estimate. The other 25 represent 43.86% of the sample. That is a measure of what was visible at that stage, rather than a count of stores that never provided an estimate.
Where you can compute a useful estimate with the product and destination already known, show it in the cart summary. If the delivery postcode is missing, ask for the postcode or show a provisional range with a clear condition. Give the date beside the actual price and delivery option. A shopper should not have to open a separate policy page to see what a faster option buys them.
Give dates only as specific as the shipment evidence allows
The study’s product-page-and-checkout comparison classified 33.3% of retailers under generic day-count range and another 33.3% under specific calendar date. Its calendar date range and receive-by categories were 21.1% and 8.7%. A range gives a shopper more information than a carrier speed alone when the endpoints already include fulfillment time. A receive-by label goes further, so reserve it for a commitment the store can support under the stated conditions.
For example, a person checking out late Thursday sees an estimate of Tuesday through Thursday for standard delivery and Monday through Tuesday for express. If they need it Sunday, neither option supports an affirmative answer. Changing the shipping speed will not change that decision if the warehouse cannot hand over the parcel until Monday. Check cutoff, destination, stock location and the shipping option against the store’s latest estimate.
On an order with two packages, show the separate arrival windows if the shopper needs both items by the same day. A fast estimate for one item cannot answer a question about the complete order. Confirm the latest window for each package before treating the shopper’s deadline as met.
Keep the checkout answer and the final promise in sync
An estimate can change when the shopper edits an address, adds a made-to-order item or passes a warehouse cutoff. Recalculate the arrival window and show the new dates before asking them to pay. If a message offers a checkout link, it should point to the same basket and let the shopper see any updated date before completing payment. A useful reply tells the shopper what can still arrive by their deadline, or what information is needed to check.
Track deadline questions that arrive before payment, the share answered with a usable date and paid orders within a fixed window. Record changes between the first quoted estimate and the final checkout date, then check actual arrival against the final promise. A higher completion rate is more valuable when it does not come with more late deliveries and avoidable service requests.
Study data
| Measure | Value | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Retailers tested | 57 retailers | One test purchase at each retailer |
| Mini-carts showing a delivery estimate | 32 retailers | Count of retailers with an estimate visible in the mini-cart |
| Mini-carts without a delivery estimate | 25 retailers | Remainder of the tested sample after 32 of 57 displayed an estimate |
| Day-count range | 33.3% | Generic duration range such as 3–5 days |
| Specific calendar date | 33.3% | Specific date shown as a promise format |
| Specific calendar date range | 21.1% | Estimated dates spanning a calendar interval |
| Receive-by specific date | 8.7% | The figure’s receive-by specific date category |
| Standard number of days | 1.8% | The figure’s standard number of days category |
| No delivery estimate | 1.8% | No estimate in this product-page-and-checkout assessment |
| Shopper-nominated delivery date | 0% | No observed nominated dates in the chart |
| Only stock availability shown | 0% | No observed stock-only format in the chart |
| Days until ready to ship | 0% | No observed ready-to-ship-only format in the chart |
| Retailers offering weekend delivery | 0 retailers | No retailer offered weekend delivery in the tested scenario |
| Measure | Value | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Sites without a delivery date in Baymard’s checkout benchmark | 41% | Sites that did not use a delivery date |
What changes when you compare the figures
| Comparison | Result | Calculation |
|---|---|---|
| Mini-carts without a delivery estimate | 25 retailers | = 57 - 32 |
| Share without a mini-cart delivery estimate | 43.86% | = (57 - 32) / 57 * 100 |
| Share showing a mini-cart delivery estimate | 56.14% | = 32 / 57 * 100 |
| Share in the two most common promise formats | 66.6% | = 33.3 + 33.3 |
| Share in the three explicit calendar formats | 63.1% | = 33.3 + 21.1 + 8.7 |
| Gap between specific date ranges and receive-by dates | 12.4 percentage points | = 21.1 - 8.7 |
Methodology and sources
We used the published 32-of-57 mini-cart count in section 6.2.5 and computed the remainder. We compared the separately coded product-page-and-checkout formats in Figure 07 using the displayed percentages. The overall study placed one order at each of 57 large U.S. retailers. Baymard’s 41% result is from a separate UX benchmark with an unpublished item base. The two sources measure different things. We did not combine them or measure what any date format does to sales.
Download the source data (CSV)
Download the calculations (CSV)
Related reading
Delivery option statistics and checkout abandonment
Cross-border checkout statistics for duties, delivery and buyer trust
Free shipping checkout statistics and how to test a minimum spend
Sustainable delivery checkout statistics and the price trade-off
Paid delivery subscription statistics and why shoppers cancel
Sources and definitions
parcelLab and ShipStation, U.S. eCommerce Shipping Experience Study 2025
Baymard Institute, Use “Delivery Date” Not “Shipping Speed”
The source data includes the population, period, denominator and limitations for every figure.